Rangers Must Resist Temptation For the Shiny New Toy

BUFFALO, NY - JANUARY 31: Buffalo Sabres center Jack Eichel (9) appears to be grimacing during warmups prior to the New Jersey Devils and Buffalo Sabres NHL game on February 25, 2021, at KeyBank Center in Buffalo, NY. (Photo by John Crouch/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

The Rangers have always had an expensive taste when it comes to players throughout the franchises history. Whether that be spending big money when it comes to free agency or selling the farm to land the big name via trade. As things would have it the Rangers are naturally in the eye of the storm again with the rumors that Buffalo will move on from Jack Eichel.

Now don’t misinterpret me here when I say that Jack Eichel is an absolute superstar but right now in this current environment he’s the wrong fit for the New York Rangers. In a time where the salary cap either remaining flat or it will only go up incrementally it’s extremely hard to fit a 10M dollar a year player under the cap. Let’s also not forget that Eichel is one of the best centers in the entire league and Buffalo isn’t going to exactly give away their franchise player just yet.

The asking price for the Rangers to land Eichel will most certainly be steep and not just in terms of draft capital but also in prospects and NHL talent. If I were Kevyn Adams I would most certainly be asking for one of Kaapo Kakko or Alexis Lafreniere, not to mention Filip Chytil, Vitali Kravtsov, or Nils Lundkvist. Lafreniere and Kakko should most likely be non-starters for the Rangers but where it starts to get interesting is Chytil. Everyone knows the Rangers have an issue of depth down the middle so the obvious solution shouldn’t be to trade your young developing center. If by somehow the NYR can land Eichel but it costs Chytil in the deal it’ll also likely signal the end of Mika Zibanejad’s time as a Ranger as well which will deplete the Blueshirts depth even more.

Just for reference, remember when the Rangers acquired Rick Nash? It took moving two of your top 3 centers plus draft capital and that move didn’t vault the Rangers to a Cup like everyone believed it would. While Nash was a really good Ranger, the 2012-2013 Rangers suffered from a lack of quality depth down the middle because they weren’t able to replace what Dubinsky and Anisimov brought to the table. Trading Chytil in any package for Eichel and then losing Zibanejad due to the cap constraints would be nearly the same thing.

Yes, the Blueshirts would acquire a top tier level center in Eichel but again you’re left wondering what they exactly have behind him.

Aside from weakening your already weak center depth, the Rangers should look to steer clear from any potential Eichel deal at this point because a trade for him doesn’t make this team an elite Cup contender. If you have to sacrifice two or three NHL pieces in a trade and then additional pieces due to cap casualties, then how exactly are you supposed to build a contending roster?

It’s not the most popular opinion but right now a trade for Eichel isn’t in the Rangers best interest. You can most certainly improve and become a better team by acquiring better depth centers and not always going after the biggest most shiny toy on the market.

This isn’t like the NBA where superstar players dominate the games, you need complete teams to become champions. It never hurts having top quality talent but most times the last team standing June has the best and most complete all around team. Take a look at prior Cup winners if you don’t believe me, it’s not about having the best top line center, it’s about having the best depth overall down the middle.

Click HERE for more New York Rangers content courtesy of 30 on Broadway

Embed from Getty Images


  • Nick has been an integral member of TheFHN since the founding of the network. A hockey player in various levels since a young age and a lifelong Rangers fan, Nick bleeds blue. As a podcaster for the past 8 years, Nick is 1/2 of the team for the Two 4 Roughing and 30 on Broadway Talking Blueshirts podcasts. In addition to the podcasts, he is a writer for 30 on Broadway OT.


  1. It will be steep but it wont cost Lafreniere or Kakko. No team will trade Buffalo a prospect of that caliber. Most teams don’t even have a prospect of that caliber, let alone 2. The Devils wouldn’t give Jack Hughes, for instance.

    Im wary of Eichel because even though he’s super talented he doesn’t strike me as a winner. And the assets we’d have to give up plus the 10M salary make it even harder to swallow.

    • Reportedly the word was that it would take one or the other to get a deal done now before the offseason but I agree with you that I don’t see that high level of a prospect moving. To me, it makes more sense for the Rangers to wait this out and see how much worse it gets in Buffalo to hopefully get the upfront cost of player/prospect/pick down and the collateral damage down if they decide to make the move. Even so, I agree with you on your 2nd point – I’m very leery of adding Eichel and I understand the talent level and him being wasted in Buffalo (we talk about that more on the latest 30 on Broadway podcast)

    • I agree with your last part for sure. that’s why I’m so wary of the Rangers making a huge push for him. I will say LA has the assets needed to make a deal their center depth is insane with Kupari, Byfield, Vilardi, and Turcotte.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here